Obtain free Delivery updates

We’ll ship you a myFT Each day Digest e-mail rounding up the newest Delivery information each morning.

Cargill’s head of ocean transport has referred to as on the transport trade to offer wind energy an opportunity in its efforts to decarbonise, as one of many world’s largest marine freight operators prepares to check using sails on a midsized vessel.

Jan Dieleman, president of the US agricultural dealer’s transport enterprise, mentioned some shipowners had been too sceptical of proposals to propel giant cargo vessels utilizing wind, a whole lot of years after sailors began utilizing engines as a substitute of sails to energy ships.

He added that wind energy was “underestimated”.

“We’ve an trade that has been focusing solely on the zero-carbon fuels for a very long time,” he mentioned. “Some persons are sceptical [of sails] from a technical perspective and so they really feel very strongly that you simply shouldn’t alter their ship. [Other shipowners] don’t need to take all the danger [of investing without support from their customers].”

Cargill has had a earlier foray into wind ship propulsion. In 2011, it introduced an settlement to put in an enormous sail on the Aghia Marina cargo ship, in partnership with German firm SkySails. In a 2015 replace, Cargill mentioned its venture with SkySails had “encountered obstacles”.

Dieleman’s feedback come amid a fractious debate between nations over decarbonise the worldwide transport trade, which carries as much as 90 per cent of world commerce however stays nearly fully depending on fossil fuels. The trade faces rising strain from regulators in addition to clients reminiscent of Amazon, Unilever and Ikea, who’ve pledged to make use of solely zero-emission ships by 2040.

Delivery teams investing in decarbonisation, nonetheless, are divided on the perfect options. Corporations are betting on a variety of fuels together with methanol and ammonia, in addition to large kites that may use wind to propel ships, regardless of issues over whether or not different fuels can be inexpensive or accessible at scale.

Dieleman spoke to the Monetary Occasions as Cargill launched a ship, chartered by the agriculture group and owned by Japan’s Mitsubishi, which it mentioned has been retrofitted with two 37.5 metre-high sails. Dieleman mentioned the Pyxis Ocean bulk service, which might carry as a lot as 81,000 tonnes of cargo in line with knowledge supplier MarineTraffic, is more likely to transport corn from Brazil to Denmark on its first cargo.

However he admitted that Cargill, which itself has been criticised for driving deforestation and local weather change, couldn’t tackle all the danger for the transport trade. He added the buying and selling home might battle to revenue from its preliminary funding within the wind-powered vessel.

Danish firm Maersk, the world’s second-largest container transport group, beforehand offered a vessel after evaluation discovered that putting in sails on the ship had solely led to an 8 per cent drop in gasoline consumption in a 12 months.

“Are we going to get our a reimbursement on this one? I don’t suppose so . . . It’s a proof of idea,” Dieleman mentioned, declining to disclose how a lot Cargill had invested. However he mentioned that low-carbon options reminiscent of inexperienced methanol or ammonia presently price as much as 4 instances as a lot as fossil fuels, which means wind energy could possibly be used alongside inexperienced fuels to save cash if it proves profitable.

Governments have additionally supported bringing again wind energy. Final 12 months, six nations together with France and Spain submitted a paper to the UN’s Worldwide Maritime Organisation (IMO), stating wind propulsion techniques had been “prepared, sufficiently mature and accessible” to assist scale back emissions.

Local weather specialists additionally agree that wind might play a task in decarbonising transport, however add that its function is restricted in an period when shipowners use more and more giant vessels to serve clients who anticipate speedy and dependable shipments.

Tristan Smith, a transport and power researcher at College School London, mentioned utilizing sails was “typically viable” however much less sensible on container ships, which have much less deck house, or on routes the place wind is much less beneficial. Environmentalists have additionally mentioned that stronger regulatory incentives are wanted for transport teams to put money into inexperienced know-how.

In July, diplomats on the IMO agreed on a goal for transport to hit internet zero emissions “by or round” 2050. The end result, which adopted lobbying in opposition to stronger objectives by nations together with China, was criticised for providing the trade an excessive amount of leeway to delay decarbonisation.

Cargill has a goal to cut back emissions in its provide chain by 30 per cent by 2030. Dieleman mentioned wind energy was only one piece of the puzzle to attain that purpose.

“There are components you possibly can management and components you possibly can’t,” he mentioned. “We’d like issues like biofuels to be deployed . . . If the trade’s not going to do something completely different than in the present day, we’re simply not going to get there.”